Moral status and the wrongness of paternalismReport as inadecuate




Moral status and the wrongness of paternalism - Download this document for free, or read online. Document in PDF available to download.

Reference: David Birks, (2014). Moral status and the wrongness of paternalism. Social Theory and Practice, 40 (3), 483-498.Citable link to this page:

 

Moral status and the wrongness of paternalism

Abstract: In this paper, I consider the view that paternalism is wrong when it demeans or diminishes the paternalizee’s moral status (the Moral Status Argument). I argue that we should reject the Moral Status Argument because it is both too narrow and too broad. It is too narrow because it cannot account for the wrongness of some of the most objectionable paternalistic interventions, namely strong paternalistic interventions. It is too broad because it is unable to distinguish between wrongful paternalistic acts that are plausibly considered more wrong than other wrongful paternalistic acts.

Publication status:PublishedPeer Review status:Peer reviewedVersion:Publisher's version Funder: Wellcome Trust   Notes:© Copyright 2014 by Social Theory and Practice. This article has been made available with publisher's permission.

Bibliographic Details

Publisher: Florida State University, Department of Philosophy

Publisher Website: http://www.fsu.edu/~philo/

Publisher: Philosophy Documentation Center

Publisher Website: http://www.pdcnet.org/

Host: Social Theory and Practicesee more from them

Publication Website: http://stp.philosophy.fsu.edu/

Issue Date: 2014-7

Copyright Date: 2014

pages:483-498Identifiers

Doi: https://doi.org/10.5840/soctheorpract201440329

Issn: 0037-802X

Eissn: 2154-123X

Urn: uuid:3666af99-ff21-46fd-acf6-0583fb664935 Item Description

Type: Article: post-print;

Language: en

Version: Publisher's versionKeywords: paternalism autonomy moral status moral powers self-respectSubjects: Philosophy Ethics (Moral philosophy) Ethics of the biosciences Practical ethics Tiny URL: ora:9785

Relationships





Author: Dr David Birks - institutionUniversity of Oxford facultyHumanities Division - Philosophy Faculty researchGroupNeurointerventions

Source: https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:3666af99-ff21-46fd-acf6-0583fb664935



DOWNLOAD PDF




Related documents