Metamemory as evidence of animal consciousness: the type that does the trick.Report as inadecuate

Metamemory as evidence of animal consciousness: the type that does the trick. - Download this document for free, or read online. Document in PDF available to download.

Reference: Shea, N and Heyes, C, (2010). Metamemory as evidence of animal consciousness: the type that does the trick. Biology and philosophy, 25 (1), 95-110.Citable link to this page:


Metamemory as evidence of animal consciousness: the type that does the trick.

Abstract: The question of whether non-human animals are conscious is of fundamental importance. There are already good reasons to think that many are, based on evolutionary continuity and other considerations. However, the hypothesis is notoriously resistant to direct empirical test. Numerous studies have shown behaviour in animals analogous to consciously-produced human behaviour. Fewer probe whether the same mechanisms are in use. One promising line of evidence about consciousness in other animals derives from experiments on metamemory. A study by Hampton (Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98(9):5359-5362, 2001) suggests that at least one rhesus macaque can use metamemory to predict whether it would itself succeed on a delayed matching-to-sample task. Since it is not plausible that mere meta-representation requires consciousness, Hampton's study invites an important question: what kind of metamemory is good evidence for consciousness? This paper argues that if it were found that an animal had a memory trace which allowed it to use information about a past perceptual stimulus to inform a range of different behaviours, that would indeed be good evidence that the animal was conscious. That functional characterisation can be tested by investigating whether successful performance on one metamemory task transfers to a range of new tasks. The paper goes on to argue that thinking about animal consciousness in this way helps in formulating a more precise functional characterisation of the mechanisms of conscious awareness.

Peer Review status:Peer reviewedPublication status:PublishedVersion:Publisher's version Funder: John Fell Fund   Funder: James Martin twenty-first Century School   Funder: Oxford Centre for Neuroethics   Funder: Somerville College   Notes:Copyright 2009 Shea, N. and Heyes, C. This article is published with open access at This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.

Bibliographic Details

Publisher: Springer Netherlands

Publisher Website:

Journal: Biology and philosophysee more from them

Publication Website:

Issue Date: 2010-1


Urn: uuid:7fea2639-772d-4b6c-9e18-93a0b059ee7f

Source identifier: 251717

Eissn: 1572-8404


Issn: 0169-3867 Item Description

Type: Journal article;

Language: eng

Version: Publisher's versionKeywords: Animal consciousness Metamemory Phenomenal consciousness Meta-representation Higher order theories of consciousness Global availability Access consciousness Tiny URL: pubs:251717


Author: Shea, N - institutionUniversity of Oxford Oxford, HUM, Philosophy, Philosophy NonPostholders fundingJohn Fell Fund fundingJames M



Related documents